RSS Feed for This PostCurrent Article

Wind Turbine Stymied By Cold Weather

This is sure to stir up some controversy about the reliability of renewable energy. The following video shows a news report from Minnesota about 12 wind turbines that won’t operate in cold weather due to an issue with the hydraulic fluid. The Minnesota State Municipal Power Association paid $300,000 for each of the turbines. What an amazing and tragic oversight. The news report indicates that there’s a plan to heat the fluid but that would likely require the use of electricity or fossil fuels thereby negating the benefits of the turbine.

There’s a very good lesson to be learned here. As excited as people are about bringing clean, renewable energy to their communities they should always perform due diligence when evaluating clean energy projects or vendors. In Minnesota you would need to have absolute assurance that a system exposed to the elements (which I would imagine could get extreme in Minnesota in the winter) will perform in all weather conditions.

Trackback URL

  • I have seen news reports that they have the turbines working again which is good news. I have also seen reports that the cost per turbine was over $400K which seems high since the turbines can only generate 160kW and they are used.
  • ""The news report indicates that there’s a plan to heat the fluid but that would likely require the use of electricity or fossil fuels thereby negating the benefits of the turbine.""


    What about heating the fluid then usin the energy made by the turbine to heat the fluid for it self? I guess some experts missed that out...or not...
  • That process you recommend greatly reduces the efficiency of the wind turbine. They are only 160kW to begin with. I'm not sure how many kW it would take to keep the fluid heated but it doesn't seem like a good use of the energy from the turbine. The optimum solution would be to have the installers correct their error and have them replace the fluid.
blog comments powered by Disqus